Why I Don’t Stand For the Pledge
April 26, 2017
It’s 7:25am and all the students in first period are getting settled into their seats. The various conversations in the classroom are interrupted with the loud sound of the bell. A handful of students in the class stand facing the red, white and blue flag, place their right hands over their chests and recite the Pledge of Allegiance, a routine that has been drilled into the minds of American students since at least the 1950s.
“I Pledge Allegiance…,” says the static voice over the intercom some recite along in monotone voices. Their voices stick out in the class, contrasting the dead silence of the students who respectfully stand, facing the flag, but do not repeat the pledge. “To the flag,” the voice continues as I look around and notice that most students aren’t standing. “Of the United States of America,” and now, the teacher is getting irritated at all the students who are sitting and ignoring the pledge.
“Phones should be out of sight, and everyone should be standing for the pledge,” says the teacher. She signals the seated students to rise and recite the pledge.
The same handful are standing, and the rest of the kids in the room continue to disregard the teacher’s request to stand.
As the pledge wraps up, the few students who stood sit down, while the ones who idly sat through the pledge, are scolded, by both the teacher and other students.
“If you don’t stand for the pledge, you aren’t supporting our troops,” says an agitated student.
For many people, the pledge is a time to pay respect to the soldiers who served for our country, or as an honorific to give support to people who fought for American rights.But for others, like myself, not standing for the pledge is actually standing for something more significant. While some may be sitting apathetically, for me, it’s form of protest.
Students are opposed to standing and reciting the pledge for several different reasons. Some students dislike current events occurring in the United States such as racism, homophobia, and sexism, and not standing for the pledge as a way to silently protest. As students, acceptable forms of protest are limited. But, being silent is both an acceptable and a powerful form of protest. It’s both a choice and an effective way to make the statement that I don’t support the words in the pledge.
To me, the pledge lies when it says things such as “With Liberty and Justice for all,” because I don’t feel as if America is abiding by this phrase that is forced into our minds every morning.
I am one of these students.
According to the Oxford Dictionary, liberty is defined as “the state of being free within society from oppressive restrictions imposed by authority on one’s way of life.”
I feel as if millions of people in America are oppressed in their own ways. There are instances where some people can’t express their gender without being criticized. There are people who practice a certain religion and are criticized for that as well.
Students should be allowed to boycott the pledge if the values they believe in aren’t represented by the pledge. If certain students feel like standing for the pledge is important to them, and it makes them feel connected to their country in some way, I support that fully. But, if a student doesn’t feel the same way, it is their American right to respectfully ignore the Pledge of Allegiance.
Ace • Oct 30, 2023 at 10:14 pm
My homeroom teacher always asks us to stand for the pledge, but if you can’t stand for personal reasons, you can give a note to explain why. The teacher will read the note and understand.
Gracie • Mar 8, 2023 at 11:04 pm
Beau
Lancer • Dec 15, 2021 at 11:17 am
This was beautifully done! I applaud you!!
anonymous • Sep 16, 2021 at 8:55 am
thank you for making this article, I am a student who recently learned that standing for the pledge goes against some of my beliefs. I do not stand for the pledge. but I do respect every single one of our troops who have fought for our lives, but in my mind, the pledge has nothing to do with our troops.
Veronica Powers • Jun 30, 2021 at 11:31 pm
Reciting the Pledge of Allegiance is a ritual that is untrue for “people of color” period. When you speak of Liberty and Justice, that’s just not referencing “All People”. I understand that if you have always been able to go wherever you wanted, entered any building you wanted, sat where you wanted, spoken to with respect, you have a hard time time being sensitive to those who haven’t enjoyed those freedoms. Sensitivity to others’ feelings is the key. If everyone was treated with true equality, then there would be no problem. I have experienced attending segregated schools, not allowed to use the closest water fountain or restroom, and not allowed to enter a restaurant but handed food out of a side window. I was told by my counselor in high school when requesting college information that she didn’t know anything about “Black Colleges”. However I was motivated enough to go on the college, got my Master’s Degree and taught school for 31 years. I don’t feel that Liberty and Justice referenced in the pledge is appropriate for me.
Reess • May 12, 2021 at 8:17 am
I do not stand for the pledge, but I do respect it. Recently my friend talked to me about if I stood up or sat down during the pledge, I told her I sat. She got very angry because her dad had been in the military, and called me a practical e Gen z kid. I’m sad that she is mad at me for having my my own opinion, I wish people would respect others for their option of the pledge, and everything else.
Anonymous • Nov 9, 2020 at 5:06 pm
I feel like the pledge represents a lot of different things for different people, so it is completely valid to not agree with another person´s perspective. For me, standing for the pledge has nothing to do with the troops and instead standing for the systems and people in government who have belittled and opressed people like me for centuries and then refusing to acknowledge it. Not standing provides a small way for me to say, ¨Hey, things aren´t ok and this pledge is hiding the fact that they aren´t,¨ So because the pledge is just a false promise for me, I cannot stand for it until the promises it holds are fufilled.
Anonymous • Nov 9, 2020 at 8:04 am
I believe it is Extraordinarily disrespectful to not stand for the pledge. It is a short period of time taken from your day to respect the people who fight and die for you to be able to live in a free country. It doesn’t matter how much you disagree with the state of our country, you should always stand for those who put their lives on the line for your freedom.
Anonymous • Oct 10, 2021 at 4:42 am
PREACH!
Anonymous • Oct 29, 2021 at 10:32 am
Some people may not think it’s just about the people who died for America. But I respect your opinion.
Helena • Nov 11, 2021 at 10:07 pm
PERIOD
Amayah Kauffman • Nov 18, 2021 at 11:31 am
yessssss
Ora • Dec 15, 2021 at 8:53 am
Amen
anonymous • Feb 28, 2022 at 2:02 pm
ABSOLUTELY!!!
Anonymous • Nov 5, 2020 at 9:36 am
This is a very fair argument. Though you are still disrespecting troops. There are two sides to this argument. Many people, such as myself, believe that this respects our troops who protect our freedom. Though many others still want change for the better. These protests make complete sense. Though there is a reason for protest, this will not always be accepted. People who put their lives on the line for us do deserve respect. So, while what you stand for is fair, the way you stand for it may confuse others.
Sophia Leilani • Oct 16, 2020 at 10:23 am
I 100% agree with this. I am doing online school right now, but I recently had to do a day in in-person school. I was the only person who did not stand for the pledge. I felt lots of eyes on me and I wondered if other people did too. Thanks for sharing this1
Juliana Molina • Sep 18, 2020 at 9:50 pm
I recently have had troubles in school this year for my choice to not stand for the pledge.
I completely stand beside you as a student. We cannot and should not be scolded for having our individual beliefs.
It’s wrong to teach kids in kindergarten to stand up a regurgitate the pledge when they do not have the brain capacity to understand what they are reciting. The pledge should not be performed in school every morning.